âI need food, food to be strong for when the wolves come.â â Conan the Barbarian
Communist humor is like food:Â not everyone gets it.
Normally Iâd end a post like this with a warning, but this week Iâll put the warning straight up front. Iâm a freedom blogger with a side order of humor. Iâm not a doctor, except in my role as John Wilder â Civil War Surgeon to His Children®, Remover of Splinters and Super-Gluer® of Grievous Wounds. The following advice has worked flawlessly for me and for thousands of others. There may be some medical reason that it might not work for you. As always, I suggest you go see a doctor, even though Iâm pretty willful and just skipped that step entirely. Iâm not on any medications, so itâs hard to screw up medications that arenât there.
I think, in all seriousness, this is one of the more important personal health posts Iâve written for anyone who wants to lose weight, which from the statistics is most of the United States. Â As far as I can see, the biggest weight loss issues people normally face (besides your mother) are:
- The diet isnât working.
- Okay, itâs working. But itâs working slooooooowly.
- Wait, it didnât work this week at all.
- Iâm not sure why, but this week I gained
- Is it just me, or can everyone gain weight on a box of McDonalds® fries?
- Wine or Beer or Chocolate Shakes or Twinkies® donât have that many calories, right?
- I just walked half a mile! I need to reward myself with a Double Whopper©. Yes, with cheese.
Iâm going to make a pretty bold statement:Â I can fix every one of the issues above with one simple trick that doesnât involve Marx, Lenin, or Castro.
Just stop eating. Fast. Not fast as in âquicklyâ but fast as in fasting: not eating.
Thatâs it.
- No books.
- No seminars.
- No cash payments to TV promoters.
- No special food to buy.
- No 1-800 phone numbers.
- No special Internet offers.
- No counting calories.
- No communist dictators.
Thus, thereâs very little profit opportunity in a business like this. A cynical person might point out that the diet industry in the United States is worth about $70 billion every year, and the cost of being overweight rings in a tab of (my guess, based on decade-old numbers) of nearly half a trillion dollars in health care costs. That cynical person might also note that itâs certainly not in the interests of people who are making hundreds of billions of dollars because a problem exists to actually fix that problem.
But imagine: Just not eating . . . would save the United States $70 billion, and thatâs just for starters. It would also save a lot of money on food. But more on that later.
When people say âlisten to your bodyâ I wonder if theyâre schizophrenic or puppeteers, since those are the only people I know who talk to a body part.
Letâs talk about something more interesting: me. I wanted to wait to write this post until I had some pretty significant results â I wrote once before about fasting, and it was going well then. How about now?
- Iâve lost more than 20% of my body weight since January 1, 2019.
- I feel great.
- The average weight loss is about 1.5% a week.
- The weight loss is consistent.
- The weight loss is maintained.
- I have to shorten my belt every week or two.
- The ghost of Stalin is wondering how I did it.
Again, Iâd say that fasting costs nothing, but that wouldnât be true. Fasting has saved me lots and lots of money, which will become apparent when I describe how Iâm doing it below.
One other thing â I gave up drinking alcohol (beer, wine, etc.) as my weight loss progresses with the exception of two major milestones. I figured that, besides motivation, giving up alcohol during my weight loss would be good because alcohol is the source of at least two things: empty calories and bad decisions. Besides, you canât sit around on the back deck with a Budweiser® and claim youâre fasting. Well, you can, but youâd be using Senate-level honesty.
So what exactly did I do? I stop eating Saturday night most weeks. Then I eat again from Friday at lunch until Saturday night. In any given week, my window to eat is about 36 hours long.
Does it require willpower? Yeah. But itâs not a frightening level of willpower where I have to face the gom-jabbar or anything. I think the biggest change for me has been breaking the conditioning of âyou have to eatâ thatâs pretty prevalent. Iâll listen to people saying âyou have to eatâ when Iâm wearing size 32 jeans. Until then? Nope.
I know that the two of you who got this laughed.
Did I drink anything? Sure. Water. Tea. Coffee. Club soda. No diet soda â Iâve read that it stimulates and insulin response, and thatâs the exact opposite of what we wanted. Besides, I think diet soda tastes like I imagine antifreeze tastes. Your mileage may vary.
So no eating anything? Okay, Iâll come clean. The first few weeks I had breath mints, but then I read the label and did the math and now I donât have them at all unless I have a business meeting and donât want to have bad breath that can melt a conference table. Sugar free doesnât mean calorie free. I also brush my teeth twice as often.
I also cheat with dill pickles. At 10 to 20 calories per day, it wasnât much, and the pickles replaced salt I sweated out while exercising. Yes, every day that I could get to the gym at lunch I would exercise. It did two things â it burned a few extra calories, but after a workout Iâm never hungry, so the afternoons are hunger free.
What is a typical week like?
Sunday is always great. Generally no hunger at all. Generally no food at all, either. Not even the pickles I cheat with.
And cleanup is a breeze!
Monday is normally pretty good. I might have five calories of pickles. Or ten.
Tuesday is the toughest day. I believe whatâs happening here is that my liver is all out of glycogen, a sugar that is stored in the liver for emergency use. Any food in my digestive system is long gone. That means that on Tuesday the body has to switch over to using fat. By Tuesday night Iâm feeling pretty good. My energy levels are actually higher on Tuesday night than Tuesday morning. Tuesday is the only day I feel really hungry. The rest of the time, when I think Iâm hungry, Iâm really just . . . conditioned to be eating. When I really sit back and examine if Iâm hungry, the answer is almost always âno.â Except on Tuesday.
You guessed it â if I get horribly hungry I have a few small dill pickles.
Wednesday and Thursday look pretty much the same as each other â my energy levels are up even though Iâve gone 72+ hours without any food. Thereâs a strong focus and mental acuity that seems to emerge about this point. Itâs entirely likely that this accountâs for Shakespeareâs quote from Julius Caesar, âYon Cassius has a lean and hungry look.â I have no idea if Cassius ate pickles.
Thursday about midnight (when Iâm writing this blog) I often go upstairs and cook some broth and/or have some cheese. Total calories are about 40 (about the same as eight mints) but it seems to make sense to have this as a gentle kick-start for the digestive system. The of all food Iâve consumed during the fast would probably be less than 100 calories, and certainly less than 200 calories, and almost never any sugar. Itâs like Iâm a fashion model, but without the cocaine!
Mmmmm, water.
Friday is FOOD DAY! Iâll eat at lunch â say 11:30 or so, though one particular Friday I was feeling so good that I skipped going to lunch right away and pushed it off entirely until nearly 2pm. My longest fast is about five and a half days. I might go longer, just for grins, but five and a half days a week is worth a weekly weight loss of more than 1.5% of my body weight every week.
The weight loss is wonderful, but the other payoff is significant: on Friday, the food is amazing. The taste of crisp lettuce and tomato on a burger . . . gives me shivers. The Chick-Fil-A® nuggets become a banquet. One Friday I had tomato soup and a grilled cheese sandwich with bacon. No king ever had such wondrous flavors hit his palate. One of the reasons Iâve grown to love fasting is that food tastes so much better. I guarantee you that after going 100 hours without food, you will enjoy and savor food more than you ever have in your life.
Did you notice the big lunch buffet behind the lunch?
Food (mainly) tastes better, more flavorful, richer. That is, food that is closest to being ânaturalâ â processed junk is not appealing on day five of a fast. One Friday I had a concession stand pretzel with concession stand cheese for lunch. I threw half of it away â the pretzel tasted like paste and the cheese like a chemical byproduct meant to poison some of the horrible fist-sized spiders that only live in Australia. I never would have imagined throwing food away after not eating for five days, but then again, I never would have pictured not eating for 134 hours.
The other effect I notice at the end of a fast is that my stomach is small. I simply cannot eat as much as I used to eat. Iâm often full before I can finish a ânormalâ portion size at the local restaurant. And if I try to eat three ânormalâ meals? I get uncomfortably full.
So what do I eat during the 36 hours? Anything I want to. No limits on portions or content, with the previously mentioned exception of the wine and beer. Why no wine and beer? As I mentioned, there are a lot of bad decisions in those bottles, but also because I love a good glass of wine with a steak or a beer while Iâm at the barbeque grill. These are motivation for success. Itâs that simple.
Itâs also breakfast, the most important meme of the day.
I know that this diet might sound extreme, but Iâll counter that our current culture is probably a LOT more extreme than this diet.  Where in history has mankind had such a surplus of food? There is no point in history that weâve been as heavy as we are today, and thatâs more extreme than fasting. But letâs rewind:
A mammoth hunter back in 20,000 B.C. couldnât jump into his Fred Flintstone® car and go down to the 7-11© to pick up a Slurpee⢠when he was hungry. Instead heâd carve into the mammoth that he and Ug got the previous week. Oops, they ate it all. Now they couldnât exactly go down to Mammoth-Mart© and pick up some steaks, they had to go find one. That might mean days of hunting, and it might mean that Fred and Ug might have to focus on the hunt.
One thing thatâs for sure, the body would want to provide them with energy but not eat into the muscle needed for hunting. Thus it would pull high-quality energy from the source created just for that purpose â fat. Fat serves a very useful purpose in animals â future energy storage for times when itâs needed.
Metabolic slowdown has been observed to be much more of an issue with reduced calorie diets â your body understands that thereâs food, but just not as much as it would like. It reacts by lowering temperature and going into a semi-hibernation. But when the body has no food? Energy is actually required, so it provides it as needed. Itâs often that my best and most energetic workout of the week is on Thursday after fasting for over 100 hours.
Gym fees were waived if the mammoth stomped on you.
Do I have to workout while fasting? No, many people donât. But every calorie burned in a workout while Iâm in a fasted state is a calorie of fat. So if you do a 500 calorie workout five days in a fasted state, thatâs 2500 calories. Of fat. A pound of fat is 3600 calories, so youâve burned about 0.7 pound (500,000 kilograms) of fat for a fairly short workout. Add that up? In ten weeks thatâs 7 pounds (3.2 grams). Not bad â there are entire diets that donât provide that kind of predictable success that Iâve experienced with just one aspect of my new lifestyle.
Yes, lifestyle. When I started, my goal was to get to a weight that I had not too long after college. Now? My new final goal is to get back to my college weight. I can see that fasting some duration each week (One day? Three days? Iâm not sure.) will be a part of maintaining that goal weight â and it wonât be a burden, I actually like fasting after having done it. Itâs obvious to me that the things I tried before didnât work because they werenât simple.
This is simple.
Okay, Dr. Evil may not be a real doctor.
Fasting is also something that Dr. Fung (LINK) has said heâs used to cure (yes, cure) type II diabetic patients. As a kidney doctor, he got to see patients that had progressed pretty far toward death. Dr. Fung noted that he was pretty frustrated being told that the only thing that he could do was make these patients comfortable until they died. There was no cure.
Fung didnât accept that. Type II diabetes is a disease thatâs related to lifestyle. Itâs really part of a bigger condition known as metabolic syndrome. He began treating his patients with fasting. The farther gone they were, the longer the fasts â in some cases 14 days. He noted (and many subsequent studies have confirmed this) that fasting made them better. It increased insulin sensitivity, and that was huge.
Insulin plays many roles in the human body â I believe I recall doctors had found at least 40 regulatory influences from insulin, but I canât find that article right now, but did find a full dozen important things it does. But (if you have a functioning pancreas) two important features are that it allows your body to admit sugar to cells for use. Thatâs important. But in type II diabetes a resistance is formed and more and more insulin has to be released to transport the sugar into the cell.
Uh-oh.
Insulin also signals your body to build and store fat. So youâre using sugar poorly, but also being signaled to store more fat. Thus? Your metabolism is screwed up and your body wants to make more fat out of the sugar in your system. So Dr. Fung came up with the idea to just stop type II diabetics from eating. And it worked like a charm.
People are alive today because Dr. Fung had this idea. Let that sink in.
Am I saying that it can cure you? Dr. Fung thinks so. But he also cautions that certain diabetic medications can be dangerous and need close monitoring so you donât die, or something. Blah blah blah.
I hear theyâre going to start vaping Cheetos® soon.
But Iâm not on any medications, so this seemed like a slam dunk. I even spent $30 for a cheap-o blood sugar monitor to see if there was anything that would show up. Nah. Boring, which just means that my liver and pancreas are doing the things theyâre supposed to do.
But the other meters in the house, the scale and my belt have certainly been heading in the right direction.
The other thing Iâve noticed is that Iâve saved a lot of money. When you only have two lunches and two dinners a week, you donât spend as much on groceries and hardly anything on restaurants. Also, the fam doesnât tend to go out to dinner when Iâm fasting. Iâm certainly okay with going out, but I think they feel guilty. So thereâs that money saved, too. Oh, and the wine and beer. Not buying any of that saves money. And we all know that mixing Amazon® and beer lead to purchases of solar string lights and ceramic garden gnomes because âthose might look good on the deck.â The worst part is trying to explain to The Mrs. exactly what I was thinking . . .
I am not exaggerating when I say that I have saved thousands of dollars by fasting.
This will likely be the last post on fasting until Iâve reached my primary goal and learned what I have to do to stay there, forever. And Iâll only post that if itâs interesting.
In addition to the Doctor Fung reference, the sub-Reddit on fasting is a wealth of information â mainly good information, but you should do your own research:
Hereâs a link to the Reddit on fasting: /Fasting
Hereâs a link to a Reddit thread showing my results arenât unique:Â Reddit /Fasting Dude
Hereâs a link to about a guy who fasted for over a year:Â Scottish Fasting Dude
I maintain with intermitant fasting.
24 hour, supper to supper, every other day.
No cheats. Water and green tea with lemon.
Fung is my guru.
Sounds like a good plan to try after I hit my goal.
This is definitely food for thought…
I see what you did there!
But now I’m thinking about food . . .
I don’t think I would dive into the deep end of the pool of fasting. But I’m willing to wade in the shallow end. I’ve been doing keto for a few months and its been working great. I’ve lost 50 lbs in 9 months. Good results, but I would like to ramp it up bit. Fasting has been the buzz of late. There is no doubt it works because calorie restriction always works. So my plan is to continue the keto and also skip every other meal.
Keto did work for me, but I had difficulty staying with it. Fasting (so far) seems actually easier than limiting for me.
wow! (this posting makes me hungry! hangry?) and now, for my questions!
what *job* (or perhaps, what *kind* of job) do you have? (i am vaguely recalling other details you have mentioned in the past, and thus, i want to say “office job”) did you keep a weight “log/record” you can share? did you ever check any body fat % during your weight loss? how old are you? what kind of exercise do you do? i thought that “reduced calories” would cause the body to lower metabolism?
i might have to read some of those links (but i probably won’t manage to get around to that…)
i don’t think fasting will work for me (but at this instant, i am thinking i might give it a try…) i was going to add more, but i think this is enough for this moment!
I am a 55 year old bricklayer. My(3rd) wife is 28. We have a boy about to turn 5 and a girl just turned 3.
Live on a farm, animals, garden etc.
As you may imagine we are very busy.
My energy level is very high, sleep 5-6 hours. Mental clarity crackling.
6′ tall, 190lbs.
Rock and roll!
thanks Jim! (i was asking John, but i appreciate that you added your input!) if only i didn’t have so many other demands on my time, maybe i would participate more in all of the various discussions going on… and usually when I get some more free time, those topics have become “ancient history” (although some topics simply *evolve* and i can just read all the old postings and jump in on the newest ones!)
Yeah, the posts may not be the same, but many of them rhyme.
Mainly office-ish. I keep a pretty up to date log with weights, notes on fasting days, and even blood glucose. I have seen at least some evidence of lowered metabolism, but only while fasting, and only on day four or so. Feel free to email me with more questions!
Americans want to have a civil war over homosexuals, abortion, and illegal immigrants, but no one cares that the USA is a bankrupt warmongering police state.
FWIW, I’m a keto guy who does what they call intermittent fasting, but is probably better described as time restricted eating. I’ll eat at 5:30 to 6:00 or so in the evening then not again until noon the next day. Some days I skip that noon meal and fast until dinner (one meal a day, or OMAD)
I spent from last June until early November doing alternate day fasts. Fasting all day on Sunday, Tuesday and Thursday, eating M,W,F and Saturday. It worked out to be 42 hour fasts most of the time. That worked out well, and I lost about 15 pounds, but then it got harder to lose again and I started having GI problems. Now I’m up most of that 15.
Since the first of the year I’ve done a couple of alternate days, and once did all three fasting days in a row.
If you know Dr. Fung, you probably know Megan Ramos by her work or blog posts or whatever. They have done two different fasting podcasts but have stopped, apparently because they don’t like that people outside of their clinic have taken fasting beyond their medical experiences and do the typical American “if a little is good, a lot must be better”. They don’t want that message associated with the clinic. It’s hard enough getting the medical profession to listen to the simple ideas like short fasts or cutting carbs to reverse diabetes. They don’t want to have to defend people doing long fasts, or “dry fasts” on their own.
Yes – dry fasting is nuts. On my first fast, I was going to end it after three days, but felt so good I kept going. I take an occasional week off from fasting (especially around business trips) but find I’m looking forward to getting back on the fast when it’s done. I decided to stick with “no more than five-ish” days for now, because I don’t want to experience any issues.
Dr. Fung speaks and writes pretty well, and I try to stick to his guidelines. I’ll look up Megan. Thanks!
Megan Ramos runs Dr. Fung’s clinic. She’s a medical researcher by degree and describes herself as Dr. Fung’s main guinea pig.
If you’ve read much on the IDM website, you’ve probably read her writings. She also has given talks at many of the low carb conferences.
YES! Okay. Yup.
Yup – you’re right.
Eat to live, don’t live to eat.
Occasional nice restaurant, never fast food.
Shop on the perimeter of grocery store, fresh food.
Get outside, work and play.
Agreed! Great advice. I’ll admit that my problem was the triad of work-fitness-family. I only had time for two, so I did work-family. Now? Much more fitness-family.
Priorities.